Showing posts with label DMCA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label DMCA. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 17, 2012

The Great Blackout of 2012: Websites to Protest Online Piracy Act

As prominent websites such as Wikipedia, Reddit, Boing Boing, and thousands of others prepare to participate in a global web blackout to protest the terms of pending intellectual property legislation called the Stop Online Piracy Act ("SOPA"), there are growing reports that the legislation already may have been shelved.

As detailed in my November post, SOPA and two other similar bills making their way through Congress - -  the PROTECT IP Act and the Online Protection and Digital ENforcement Act ("OPEN") - - have drawn Hollywood and the tech community to opposite sides of the IP battlefield. Proponents of the proposed new law argue it is necessary to protect against piracy and copyright infringement by offshore "rogue sites." However, many have opposed the bill because proposed to penalize innovators, not only infringers, and will punish inventors in a manner that violates the First Amendment. 

Many law professors, tech companies, free speech advocates and political figures have taken issue with the legislation which, among other things, permits the U.S. attorney general to obtain court order against targeted website that would result in Internet service providers having to take the accused sites offline. For example, section 102 of SOPA provides that, once a service provider is served with such an order, the service provider must take "technically feasible and reasonable measures designed to prevent access by its subscribers located within the United States to the foreign infringing site (or portion thereof)" within five days after being served with a copy of the order.  Critics point to that provision as constituting a draconian measure that will chill speech and allow websites to be shuttered before charges are ever proven in court, and even if they are only tangentially involved in the accused conduct.

On Monday, Jimmy Wales, Wikipedia's founder, announced on Twitter that Wikipedia would join the blackout protest, in which participating websites plan to go dark for 24 hours on Wednesday, January 18, 2012.  Google has announced it will participate in the protest, but without shutting off its services.  And President Obama joined the fray over the weekend, opposing the current version of SOPA, OPEN and the PROTECT IP Act.  While recognizing that online piracy harms the U.S. economy, threatens jobs and hurts certain innovative companies and entrepreneurs," the White House announced, "[a]ny effort to combat online piracy must guard against the risk of online censorship of lawful activity and must not inhibit innovation by our dynamic businesses large and small."

Darrell Issa, chair of the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, announced that he had received assurances from House Majority Leader Eric Cantor that the anti-piracy legislation would not move to the House floor without a consensus. He also postponed his committee's hearing on the impact of Domain Name Service ("DNS") and search engine blocking on the Internet, which had been scheduled for Wednesday, the day of the blackout protest.

Watch this space for further developments, although not necessarily on Wednesday.

Friday, November 18, 2011

Anti-Circumvention Rulemaking - Comment While You Can

The U.S. Copyright Office is conducting rulemaking proceedings related to the anti-circumvention provisions of the Copyright Act in accordance with the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA).  If you represent copyright owners, educational institutions, libraries, archives, scholars, researchers and members of the public, the time to submit your proposal is now. (Comments are due on December 1, 2011, by 5:00 pm.)

The DMCA permits the Librarian of Congress to designate certain classes of works as exempt from the anti-circumvention measures where circumvention is directed at certain noninfringing uses.  To that end, the Copyright Office is attempting to determine whether the anti-circumvention provisions are likely to affect users' abilities to make noninfringing uses of particular categories of works.

As part of its rulemaking process, the Copyright Office is soliciting written proposals to designate particular classes of works.  The submission form can be found here. 

Wednesday, November 16, 2011

Hollywood vs. Tech – Online Piracy Legislation Divides IP Community

Congress is considering legislation that is dividing the intellectual property community, pitting Hollywood against tech. The Senate's version of the proposed new law is S.968, Preventing Real Online Threats to Economic Creativity and Theft of Intellectual Property Act of 2011, or "PROTECT-IP". In the House, the bill is HR 3261, the Stop Online Piracy Act, or "SOPA".

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the MPAA, the RIAA, the Screen Actors Guild, and several other film, music and other entertainment groups support the legislation, which is described as an measure that will help prevent online threats to economic creativity and theft of intellectual property. However, several tech, education, consumer protection groups and privacy advocates are vehemently opposed to the bill, including Google, Yahoo, Facebook, the Electronic Frontier Foundation ("EFF"), Public Knowledge and others. EFF describes the bill as "the worst piece of IP legislation we’ve seen in the last decade" and Public Knowledge describes it, when combined with the anti-circumvention provisions of the Copyright Act, as "a frightening combination."

According to the RIAA the law is needed, constitutes a necessary step in the evolution of IP enforcement provisions as digitization and high speed Internet access has increased, and permits the Justice Department to seize criminal websites engaged in criminal activity. On the other hand, some critics say the proposed legislation would require payment processers and advertising services to sever ties with Internet websites alleged to be violating intellectual property rights -- before the allegations are ever proven in court -- and the allegations do not even need to concern actual circumvention if intellectual property protections. That is, if passed, the new law would expand the scope of conduct to ensnare not only people who may aid circumvention by others, but also people who "possibly aid people who possibly aid circumvention."

SOPA, the House bill, was introduced in late October and the House Judiciary Committee is conducting a hearing on it this morning.

Tuesday, June 14, 2011

Should Illegal Streaming be a Felony? New Registrar of Copyrights Says Yes.

The new Register of Copyrights, Maria A. Pallante recently testified in Washington D.C. before the U.S. House Subcommittee on Intellectual Property, Competition and the Internet, a subcommittee of the House Judiciary Committee. On her first day in her position, she argued in favor of increasing the potential penalties available for willful, large scale, egregious and illegal copyright infringement, particularly with respect to illegal streaming of copyrighted works over the Internet.

The Registrar's comments - which were formally directed at promoting investment and protecting online commerce and "Promoting Investment and Protecting Commerce Online" and focused on the Artists Rights and Theft Prevention Act (the "ART Act"), the No Electronic Theft Act (the "NET Act") – focused specifically at illegal streaming of, motion pictures, television programs (including broadcasts of sporting events) and other copyrighted works. In that context, she addressed criminal penalties for willful, large scale, egregious and illegal copyright infringement. She testified about the potential impact that illegal streaming has on the economic market for copyrighted works.

Ms. Pallante argued that criminal infringers are doing massive harm to copyright owners and that without the felony option for illegal streaming, prosecutors are hamstrung in their efforts to protect them. She did acknowledge that the issues involved are global and shied away from questions concerning what criminal penalties in the U.S. might do to curb overseas infringement of domestic works.  Ms. Pallante raised what she described as two safeguards that could help protect against unwarranted prosecutions, namely, that the Department of Justice has discretion over whom to prosecute, and that the accused conduct must rise to the level of being willful. 

However, she also recognized the legitimate uses that can be made of the same technologies used for illegal streaming and admitted that finding the appropriate balance between these interests presents one of the most difficult issues that Congress will need to addressed.

Ms. Pallante also announced her goal of improving the U.S. copyright registration system to making it the premiere copyright registration system in the world.

Ms. Pallante was joined at the hearing by Sandra Aistars, Executive Director of the Copyright Alliance and Michael O'Leary, Executive Vice President of the Motion Picture Association of America, who also both spoke in favor of enacting provisions to make illegal streaming a felony.

Ms. Pallante's prepared statement is available here.  A webcast of the full hearing is available here.

Thursday, December 9, 2010

Google Announces New Anti-Piracy Rules

Last week, Google announced new rules that the company intends to implement to address a growing number of issues related to "bad apples who use the Internet to infringe copyright."

Among the new rules are the company's promise to build tools to make it easier for copyright owners to submit takedown requests under the The Digital Millennium Copyright Act; to act more quickly (within 24 hours) on reliable copyright takedown requests; to make takedown requests publicly searchable; and to improve the company's “counter-notice” tools for those who believe their content may have been wrongly removed and enable public searching of takedown requests. The company also announced the new rules would attempt to address certain piracy issues that have been raised about its "autocomplete" service and "AdSense" advertising program.

Autocomplete uses an algorithm that offers Internet searchers suggestions of proposed search terms that are similar to those being typed. It has been criticized by some content owners for suggesting terms in a way that assists piracy efforts. The new rules are intended to attempt to prevent the service from displaying terms the company can identify as being most frequently used for piracy purposes. Google also explained that it would be improving its AdSense program to help identify, and in some instances expel from the program, violators of the company's antipiracy standards.

The full text of the announcement, which also addressed other planned changes, is available here.

Monday, December 6, 2010

Viacom Files Opening Brief In YouTube Appeal

On Friday, Viacom - the owner of major content providers such as Paramount Pictures, Comedy Central and MTV filed its opening brief in its appeal against Google's video sharing website, YouTube.  The filing comes as the latest move in the four year old copyright infringement dispute concerning the posting of pirated video clips on YouTube.

In June, a federal district court in Manhattan ruled that YouTube was protected by the safe harbor provisions of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), 17 U.S.C. § 512(c), and that despite having "generalized knowledge" that there were infringing postings on its website, the company was not itself liable for copyright infringement because it did not have adequate notice of the particular infringements at issue.  Where it had particularized knowledge, the court found, it had promptly taken the infringing postings down. 

In enacting the DMCA, Congress created procedures to facilitate the policing of copyright infringements on the Internet without imposing an undue burden on Internet service providers (ISPs). The procedures are intended to provide specified ISPs with a "safe harbor" from liability for copyright infringement.

In its opening brief, Viacom argues that YouTube intentionally facilitated the copyright infringement and should not be protected by the safe harbor provisions at all.  According to Viacom, to retain the safe harbor protection under § 512(c), YouTube had an obligation to take reasonable steps to prevent further infringement and should have used tools it had at its disposal to curtail the infringement it had fostered.  Viacom asserts that YouTube was aware of massive infringement, “welcomed” the infringement and sought to expand and profit from it.  It cites internal email in which YouTube acknowledged, for example, that that if it “just remove[d] the obviously copyright infringing stuff,” traffic would “go from 100,000 views a day down to about 20,000 views or maybe even lower.”   It also argues that the lower court erred in not finding that the evidence it presented sufficiently established that YouTube knew of the infringing activity on its site and thus had "aware[ness] of facts or circumstances from which infringing activity is apparent” taking it out of the safe harbor provisions. 

On the other hand, YouTube will likely argue in response that the lower court correctly applied the DMCA's safe harbor provisions and that it did not have “actual knowledge” of the specific acts of infringement at issue and that its "generalized knowledge" was insufficient to disqualify it for those protections. 

One interesting issue is whether the Supreme Court's decision in Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Studios Inc. v. Grokster, Ltd., 545 U.S. 913 (2005) applies or is even instructive with respect to Viacom's argument that YouTube should at least be held secondarily liable for copyright infringement for its encouragement of infringing activity.  The lower court rejected the Grokster argument and found that the case was inapplicable because it did not involve ISPs and was based on common law rather than the statutes at issue in this case.  However, there are important parallels between the two cases:  each case attempts to address secondary liability issues and each is concerned with striking an appropriate balance between promoting innovation and protecting copyright rights.  Thus, the the Second Circuit may find the Supreme Court's guidance in Grokster instructive on the secondary liability issues before it.

The lower court's opinion and order in, Viacom International Inc., et al. v. YouTube, Inc., et al., Case No. 07 Civ. 2103 (June 23, 2010) is available here.  Viacom's opening brief in its appeal, now pending in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit as Case No. 10-3270, is available here. 

Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Wikipedia, Censorship, and the FBI

On July 22, the David Larson, Deputy General Counsel for the FBI served the online encyclopedia Wikipedia with a cease and desist letter demanding that Wikipedia remove the FBI's seal from its website.

He pointed out that the FBI Seal is an official insignia of the Department of Justice with the primary purpose of authenticating the official communications and actions of the FBI, and that there are regulations requiring requests for authorizations to use the seal, but that Wikipedia had not received any such authorization.

He also explained that "The inclusion of a high quality graphic of the FBI seal on Wikipedia is particularly problematic, because it facilitates both deliberate and unwitting violations of these restrictions by Wikipedia users." He further explained that unauthorized reproduction or use of the FBI Seal is prohibited by a criminal law and criminal procedure section of the US Code, Title 18, section 701, and demanded that Wikipedia remove the seal from its website.

That section provides:

§ 701. Official Badges, Identification Cards, Other Insignia

Whoever manufactures, sells, or possesses any badge, identification card, or other insignia, of the design prescribed by the head of any department or agency of the United States for use by any officer or employee thereof, or any colorable imitation thereof, or photographs, prints, or in any other manner makes or executes any engraving, photograph, print, or impression in the likeness of any such badge, identification card, or other insignia, or any colorable imitation thereof, except as authorized under regulations made pursuant to law, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than six months, or both.
He did not cite any provisions of the Lanham Act or the Copyright Act, or any suggestion that Wikipedia might be liable for contributory or vicarious copyright infringement – presumably based on the belief that either citing the criminal code provisions would be more threatening or that the fair use defense would trump the FBI's claims.

It bears noting that Wikipedia does not always include high resolution versions of copyrighted works on its site, and the FBI might have been able to make a stronger case under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DCMA) based on the continued inclusion of the high resolution version of the seal on its website, particularly when a lower resolution is available. (If Wikipedia is considered a service provider under the DCMA, it would have a difficult time arguing that it should come within the Act's safe harbor provisions in light of Wikipedia's position, which makes plain that it has no plans to block access to the high resolution version or remove it from the site.)

In any event, for whatever reasons, the FBI's "demand" elicited a sharp response from Wikipedia's general counsel, Mike Godwin, who fired back on July 30 with a treatise on statutory construction and an explanation that the principle of ejusdem generis – "of the same kind" – a rule in statutory construction that applies where a word is ambiguous or inherently unclear; in its application, when general words follow the enumeration of a particular class of persons or things, the general words shall be construed as applicable only to persons or things of the same general nature or kind as those enumerated. Mr. Godwin explained that under this principle, the statute does not apply to Wikipedia's use of the seal in its encyclopedia because the statute was only intended to protect the public against the use of a recognizable assertion of authority with intent to deceive, hardly what Wikipedia was doing.

Mr. Godwin concluded that Wikipedia believed it was "compelled as a matter of law and principle to deny your demand for removal of the FBI Seal" and that it was "prepared to argue our view in court."

Like most high profile attempts to call for a prior restraint on speech, the FBI's strategy seems to have backfired, at least insofar as it has resulted in calling greater attention to the availability of the high resolution version of the FBI's seal on Wikipedia's site. Watch this site for further developments.

Monday, July 26, 2010

Librarian of Congress Determines That "Jailbreaking" Smartphones Is Fair Use

The Librarian of Congress has announced a new regulation that exempts certain classes works from the provisions of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DCMA)'s anti-circumvention provisions. The exemptions offer new legal protections to consumers who wish to "jailbreak" their smart phones to permit the phones to run applications other than those approved by the phone's manufacturer.

The practice of jailbreaking has long subjected consumers to accusations of copyright infringement. As a result, the Electronic Frontier Foundation applied for the exemptions as part of the Congressionally mandated rulemaking process.

Apple responded to the request and opposed it, asserting that copyright law prohibits consumers from installing unapproved programs on its iPhones. The Librarian rejected that argument.

The rulemaking proceeding was mandated by the DCMA, which permits the Librarian of Congress to exempt certain classes of works from the prohibition against circumvention of technological measures that control access to copyrighted works, or "access controls." The Librarian of Congress, together with the Register of Copyrights, conducted rulemaking proceedings to determine whether there were particular classes of works as to which users were likely to be adversely affected in their ability to make noninfringing uses due to the prohibition on circumvention of those access controls. They were required to (1) assess whether the implementation of access control measures diminishes the ability of individuals to use copyrighted works in ways that are not infringing, and (2) to designate any classes of works with respect to which users have been adversely affected in their ability to make noninfringing uses.

The Librarian of Congress ultimately determined that the DCMA's prohibition against circumvention of access controls for copyrighted works should not apply to six classes of works, and found that:
[W]hen one jailbreaks a smartphone in order to make the operating system on that phone interoperable with an independently created application that has not been
approved by the maker of the smartphone or the maker of its operating system, the modifications that are made purely for the purpose of such interoperability
are fair uses.
The new rule also provides new protection for certain amateur video remix artists, in order to adequately present the speech-related purpose of their uses. The exemption allows them to use short excerpts from specified DVDs, in order to create new, noncommercial works for purposes of criticism or comment, if the artist believes that the circumvention is necessary to fulfill the purpose of the comment or criticism.

The new regulation is available here.

Tuesday, July 20, 2010

Children's Author Abandons Copyright Infringement Case Against Scribd

On July 15, the parties in a closely watched copyright infringement action against Scribd, Inc. requested that the federal district court dismiss the case.

San Francisco-based Scribd is a self-described "social publishing site, where tens of millions of people share original writings and documents." It stores the materials and permits users to search and retrieve them online.

A Houston author named Elaine Scott filed the suit against San Francisco based Scribd in September, 2009. Scott, who writes children's books, discovered one of her titles on Scribd's website and sent the company a takedown notice. Scribd complied, but not before approximately 100 copies of Scott's work were downloaded.

Scott's complaint presented a relatively new theory of copyright infringement in which she alleged that Scribd's system of copying copyrighted works and inserting them into a filtering system without authorization and without compensation to the authors constituted infringement of her exclusive copyright rights. Scribd maintained that the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DCMA)'s safe harbor provisions shielded the company from liability because Scribd removed Scott's work after receiving a takedown notice. Scribd also maintained that its use of the work constituted fair use. Although the case was reportedly settled, Scribd's attorney explained that Scribd did not make any payment in exchange for Scott abandoning her case. The parties filed a stipulation requesting that the case be dismissed with prejudice.

The case is Elaine Scott v. Scribd, Inc., U.S. District Court, Southern District of Texas Case No. 4:09-CV-03039 MH.